The task
Students investigated the life cycle of butterflies by observing a live butterfly as it developed through its life cycle stages in a commercially prepared butterfly habitat; and by accessing information in reference materials. Students recorded their observations in journals and reported what they learned in writing and artwork.

Circumstances of performance
This sample of student work was produced under the following conditions:
alone in a group
in class as homework
with teacher feedback with peer feedback
timed opportunity for revision

This work sample illustrates a standard-setting performance for the following parts of the standards:
a Life Sciences Concepts: Characteristics of organisms.
b Life Sciences Concepts: Life cycles of organisms.
c Scientific Thinking: Use evidence from reliable sources.
c Scientific Tools and Technologies: Acquire information from multiple sources.
a Scientific Communication: Represent data and results in multiple ways.
b Scientific Investigation: Systematic observation.



What the work shows
b Life Sciences Concepts: The student produces evidence that demonstrates understanding of life cycles of organisms,…that all plants and animals have life cycles.
The student provides evidence of understanding of the butterfly’s life cycle by keeping a narrative journal of observations and by making a diagram that illustrates the four stages of the life cycle, three of which were personally observed.
The student summarized information about butterfly life cycles from reference sources in narrative form and in a diagram.

a Life Sciences Concepts: The student produces evidence that demonstrates understanding of characteristics of organisms, such as…the relationship between structure and function.
The student relates the structure of a butterfly’s probe to its function of getting nectar. This relationship is described in both written form and in an illustration.

c Scientific Thinking: The student uses evidence from reliable sources.
The student reports from personal observations.
The student’s bibliography lists several references used in developing the report.

c Scientific Tools and Technologies: The student acquires information from multiple sources, such as experimentation and print and non-print sources.
The student’s bibliography lists references, both print and software, used in developing the report.

a Scientific Communication: The student represents data and results in multiple ways, such as…diagrams and artwork; and technical and creative writing.
The student presents data in narrative form
(, , ) accompanied by diagrams (, ) and artwork ().

b Scientific Investigation: The student demonstrates scientific competence by completing…a systematic observation….
The student’s observations of a closed habitat were made systematically over a period of weeks. During this time, the student recorded observations of three of the stages of development of a butterfly, and used reference materials to find out about the unobserved stage.