The task
Students were asked to conduct a simple experiment in which they recorded temperature changes that accompany the melting and boiling of a pure substance. This assignment was given to students in a Science Research class.

Circumstances of performance
This sample of student work was produced under the following conditions:
alone in a group
in class as homework
with teacher feedback with peer feedback
timed opportunity for revision

This work sample illustrates a standard-setting performance for the following parts of the standards:
b Physical Sciences Concepts: Structure and properties of matter.
e Physical Sciences Concepts: Conservation of energy and increase in disorder.
a Scientific Connections and Applications: Big ideas and unifying concepts.
b Scientific Thinking: Use concepts from Science Standards 1–4.
a Scientific Tools and Technologies: Use technologies and tools.
e Scientific Tools and Technology: Recognize and limit sources of bias in data.
a Scientific Communication: Represent data and results in multiple ways.


What the work shows

b Physical Sciences Concepts:The student produces evidence that demonstrates understanding of structure and properties of matter, such as…characteristics of phase changes.
The student describes the observed process in terms of phase change characteristics.
The student describes changes in temperature in terms of molecular interactions.
The student’s hypothesis clearly relates phase change and energy.

e Physical Sciences Concepts: The student produces evidence that demonstrates understanding of conservation of energy and increase in disorder, such as kinetic and potential energy…and effects of heat and pressure.
The student describes how a transfer of energy causes a phase change.
The student describes the effects of heat in relative terms.
The student demonstrates understanding of the relationship between kinetic energy, heat, and temperature.

a Scientific Connections and Applications: The student produces evidence that demonstrates understanding of big ideas and unifying concepts, such as…cause and effect.
The student demonstrates understanding of cause and effect relationships between change of temperature and change in state of matter.

b Scientific Thinking: The student uses concepts from Science Standards 1 to 4 to explain a variety of observations and phenomena.
The student uses the concept of phase change to explain constant temperature during the observation.
The student compares the liquid and gaseous phases of water in terms of relative molecular organization and motion.

a Scientific Tools and Technology: The student uses technology and tools (such as traditional laboratory equipment…) to observe and measure…phenomena, directly…with appropriate considerations of accuracy and precision.
The student uses various pieces of laboratory equipment to observe and measure the effects of heat.

e Scientific Tools and Technology: The student recognizes and limits sources of bias in data, such as observer and sample biases.
The student indicates that calibration of the thermometer is needed in order to get an accurate temperature reading.

a Scientific Communication: The student represents data and results in multiple ways, such as numbers, tables and graphs; [and] technical…writing; and selects the most effective way to convey the scientific information.
These items and others indicate the student’s ability to convey information through technical writing. It should be noted that errors in Sample 1 should be corrected in a revision. In item 2a, for example “liquid to gas” should be corrected to “solid to liquid.” In item 4a, the water molecules are most definitely in motion at 100 degrees Celsius. The student’s logic is correct in 4a, but the statement regarding molecular motion indicates a misconception that needs to be corrected.
The student records data in tables.
The student uses a graph to represent the data recorded in the tables.

Sample 1

 


Sample 1

Sample 1

Sample 1 translation

Sample 1 translation

Sample 1 translation

Sample 1 translation

Sample 1 translation

Sample 1 translation

Sample 2

Sample 2

Sample 2

Sample 2

Sample 2 translation

Sample 2 translation

Sample 2 translation

Sample 2 translation